A Paradigm With Which To Function: Definitions Used Within These Thesi— er, Blog Entries

Sorry, a flashback to my thesis there for a moment. Thank goodness I stopped in time. I’m not really sure how you’re supposed to conjugate the plural form of thesis. Thesises? Thesisae? Thesie? Thesise?

On to the definition. ‘Fanfiction’ is a bit of a fluid term, subject to some debate if you really think about it. Debate, because we are trying to be academic and it is not academic to use terms such as ‘nitpicking’, ‘rules-lawyering’, and ‘legalistic gobbledegook’. Certainly, everything in Fanfiction.net, which is to be our primary source of materials for analysis, can easily be classed under this, but that’s not all we’ll be speaking of. Are adaptations fanfic? Does this mean the movie ‘Romeo Must Die‘ is a fanfic of ‘Romeo and Juliet’? Are ‘Sherlock‘ and ‘Elementary‘ fanfics of Sherlock Holmes? What about every Sherlock Holmes movie ever not based on the writings of Arthur Conan Doyle?

In these blogs, I will be regarding Fanfiction in roughly two groups: ‘Hard Fanfiction’, which are Fanfics written by those in no way related and authorized by the root creator of the fandom or source material in which the fanfic is based; and ‘Soft Fanfic’, which is anything written for a fandom by anyone NOT the original, root writer/creator of that fandom, but with their authorization, whether verbal (in spirit, but won’t stand up in court) or legal (they never met, but the guy signed a paper at some point that in some convoluted way says it’s okay). In legalistic terms, you can make money off ‘Soft Fanfiction’, but woe betide you if you try to do so with ‘Hard Fanfiction’. This is going by the western perspective, since in Japan, you’re perfectly free to flog all the fan manga/doujinshi you want. Hopefully, the woefully outdated west will be mature enough to adapt these more enlightened practices, which is really much better for the capitalist model they insist on both shunning and embracing.

Even as I write this down, I realize that this is a very loose and problematic definition. Sure, there are public domain materials you’re allowed to flog: Sherlock Holmes, Dracula (Mickey Mouse too if Disney wasn’t so… Disney), but in each instance, you will inevitably be in the shadow of the Titan that is THE original. Think you can live up to that?

Advertisements

3 responses to “A Paradigm With Which To Function: Definitions Used Within These Thesi— er, Blog Entries

  1. I’d be honoured by people writing hard fanfic of my work, but I acknowledge that it can cause problems. There are three ways that this is normally dealt with.

    A: Forbidding fanwork: Yeah, I’m not going to do that. I LIKE fanwork.
    B: Deciding not to look at fanwork: Well, that’d epically suck for me as it severly limits my ability to interact with my fandom and I my want to become a fan of said fanwork.
    C: Declaring that I have the power to decide what to do with fanwork: A little totallitarian, but the least of the evils. That way I don’t have to worry about complaints that I’m stealing ideas as I’ve declared ownership up front. If you don’t like it, don’t make your fanwork publicly available.

  2. Part of me wants copyright law to be modified to say that Mickey Mouse will never enter public domain. That way Disney can stop perpetually moving the goalposts to keep him, and we don’t need to worry about said goalpost moving making stuff take five hundred years after the creator dies to be fair game.

  3. I suppose that if I was a published author, I wouldn’t have a problem with people writing “Hard Fanfiction” of my works. I’d be sure to say that none of it is canonical, and I’d probably take the Terry Pratchett-style route of not reading it, lest I accidentally poach ideas, but yeah.

    By the way, SCM, the plural form is “theses.” Though maybe you already knew that and were kidding. It was hard to tell. 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s